Tuesday, 17 May 2016

Critique on “Do We Want Peace Or Unity”

The article do we want peace of unity is written by a columnist, Wan Saiful Wan Jan who worked as Chairman at Istanbul Network for Liberty since Mac 2014 until now. He also worked as Director at CfBT Education Malaysia and as a Chairman at IDEAS Autism Centre for 3 years 8 months. The article is published on 12th of Mac 2016 on The Star Online. The target audiences of this article is diversified and not confined to one scope of age, social status or specific group.

The writer’s intention is to persuade readers to consider the possibility that the attempt to create unity and integration, or the imposition of a “national” identity, is actually one of the causes of discord and disharmony. Then, the writer emphasize that he convince that the grouping and division will result in the peace among the citizens rather than detrimental to the country. Next, the writer insists that the authorities should intervene only when physical harm is caused. The writer also asserts that the Government’s role is not promotes integration but to maintain peace.

Fact and argument put forward by the writer is to raise awareness among Malaysian that people live in separate grouping will result in peace among citizens instead of detrimental to country. The writer has successfully presents an accurate and relevant data in a logical manner. Looking at the points present by the writer, he has provides multi-dimensional evidences, a few example of real life situation to support his stance. The example given was reliable in which every of it from his own view as a professional columnist.

The writer states that the Government’s role is not to promote integration but to maintain peace. Peace is not necessarily achieved through unity.  I think live in separate grouping is a good idea reveals by the writer as long as they do not harm others. Intervene of authorities to create unity will only brings a negative outcome, discord and disharmony to Malaysia. Peace is the important element that we should care about in order to produced a better environment for our country.

The tone and choice of words used by the author indicated his professionalism, with no biasness in term of language style. No notes of sarcasm are used throughout this article, and it has been delivered straightforward and honestly. There are no fear appeals or provoking words had been used throughout this article. Thus, the method of delivering points could be said neutral without playing of emotions on the readers.

Overall, looking at the points presented, the writer emphasize that he did not see live separately among people of different identities will brings detrimental to the country if it result in peace among the citizens. This article is not one-sided article as the writer already expressed a good and fair opinion for all parties. However, the writer had successfully delivered his points through the arguments laid out by him and making his stance clear.

Written by: Nur Shahazira Izzati Binti Shaharizan (A156968)


                           

No comments:

Post a Comment